Imperfect Picks

Imperfect Picks is back — and bigger.

This time it’s not just factory seconds. Alongside some High Glow and Bright Stripe Eyeliners with scuffed-up boxes but flawless formulas, you’ll find perfect Velvet Eyeshadows and Dew Tints in our original plastic-free packaging (we’ve just updated the look). All heavily discounted — up to 55% off — and all saved from landfill.

Once they’re gone, they’re gone.

Bright Stripe Eyeliner (Imperfect Pick)

$13.00

Lavender

Chinotto

Gold

White

Black

Velvet Eyeshadow (Original Packaging)

$15.00

Rose Quartz

Cool Bronze

Berry Bronze

Hazelnut

Sky

Dew Tint (Original Packaging)

$19.00

Rose

Grapefruit

Toffee

High Glow (Imperfect Pick)

$19.00

Champagne

Pearl

Bronzite

No free shipping or returns on Imperfect Picks|Buy now with 4 interest-free payments with Afterpay

Imperfect Picks

What our customers say

Lovely

Neat lightweight packaging, nice texture. Pretty stable and long wearing throughout the day so no need to reapply which is great.

Marieke 3 Oct 2025

Nice

Neat lightweight packaging, nice texture. Colour very much on the yellow/orange side so okay for some for blush but unable to double up as lip tint. Wish there was a deeper more plum/ wine coloured option that was not so orange/yellowish.

Marieke 3 Oct 2025

No smudges, no eye sting and great pigmentation

Title of review says everything. Hard to find products that dont have eye sting. It's beautiful pigment and colour!

Pei 30 Sept 2025

Great colour, smooth application

I used this for the first time as a liner, it flatters my light complexion and didn't irritate my sensitive eyes.

Kristy 23 Sept 2025

Bought this product and loved it?

Love makeup & hate plastic?